Is it legal to secretly record someone?
In September 2026 police in Victoria, Australia, charged a mother who allegedly sewed a recording device into the clothing of her seven-year-old, non-verbal autistic son, and recorded a school aide saying something the aide later apologised for. The law still treated the recording as a possible offence, which is the point worth understanding before anyone records anyone in secret.
In short: It depends on where you are, who is speaking and whether you are part of the conversation, and even if you take part, sharing a recording can be unlawful. Some places, such as the Australian state of Victoria, make it an offence to use a listening device to record a private conversation you are not part of, even for a good reason. Hong Kong’s rules are different and less direct, but secret recording can still raise issues under privacy, voyeurism and other laws, and may not help your case. Take legal advice before recording, and before using a recording.
What was reported
ABC News reported on 19 September 2026 that a mother from Gippsland had been charged under Victoria’s rules on installing and using a listening device, after allegedly sewing a recording device into her son’s clothing. The recordings allegedly captured a school aide saying “You hurt me, I’ll hurt you.” The aide apologised in writing. She told ABC that police had offered to resolve the matter without a criminal record if she admitted the charge and made a charity donation, and that she was taking legal advice and campaigning to change the law. The charge had not been decided at the time of writing.
Why a good reason may not be enough
Laws on listening devices protect everyone in a private conversation, including people who say things they should not. A device that records a conversation you are not part of can be an offence even if it captures wrongdoing. The recording may also be inadmissible, or may expose the person who made it to a claim.
Hong Kong in outline
Hong Kong has no single statute that mirrors Victoria’s listening-device law for private individuals. That does not make covert recording risk-free. Recording intimate acts or images is covered by the voyeurism offences; collecting and using recordings of identifiable people can engage the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance; planting devices may involve trespass or other offences; intercepting telephone calls or messages, or putting spyware on someone’s phone or computer, may be offences under the Telecommunications Ordinance or the Crimes Ordinance; disclosing personal data without consent can be a doxxing offence; and covert surveillance by public officers is separately regulated. Whether a recording can be used in court is a further question. This is general information, not legal advice.
If you are worried that someone is recording you
Do not discuss your concern in the place you think is being recorded, and do not search for or remove a device yourself, and tell as few people as possible. Call from somewhere else, on a phone the other person has never had access to. If you think your phone itself may be compromised, checking it is time-consuming; it is usually far cheaper to buy a new device and set up a new Apple ID or Google account, and never restore from a backup. A professional Privacy Audit can check the rooms that matter, and lawyers can advise on what to do with anything found. See Is my office bugged?
Sources
ABC News (Australia), 19 Sep 2026
General commentary on public reports, not legal advice and not a finding about any person or organisation named in those reports. Facts are as reported at the time of writing.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to secretly record someone?
It depends on the jurisdiction, whether you are part of the conversation and what is recorded. In some places, such as Victoria in Australia, recording a private conversation you are not part of can be an offence even for a good reason. Take legal advice before recording.
Is it legal to secretly record a conversation in Hong Kong?
Covert recording in Hong Kong can still be unlawful or actionable under voyeurism, interception, privacy, trespass and other laws, even though no single statute mirrors Victoria’s listening-device offence. Intercepting calls or installing spyware may be offences. Whether a recording can be used in court is a separate question. Take legal advice.
Can a secret recording be used as evidence?
Sometimes. Courts decide admissibility and weight case by case, and an unlawfully obtained recording may be excluded or may expose the person who made it to liability.
Can I put a recorder in my child’s bag to check on school?
Recording other people’s conversations without consent can be an offence in some places; in the Victoria case a parent has been charged, though the charge has not been decided. In Hong Kong too, recording other children or staff can raise privacy and other legal issues. Raise concerns with the school and take legal advice before recording. If you believe your child is being harmed, report it to the police or the Social Welfare Department; you do not need a recording to report.
What should I do if I think someone is secretly recording me?
Do not discuss it where you think you are being recorded, do not search for or remove a device yourself, tell as few people as possible, and call a specialist from elsewhere on a phone you trust. A professional Privacy Audit can check the rooms that matter.
Speak to us before you speak in that room
The first confidential consultation carries no fee, and if a Privacy Audit is not the right answer we will say so. Call from a personal device, away from the space you are concerned about.
